Jump to content

Examples of corruption in Australia


Bruce Tuncks

Recommended Posts

I like to think that here we are less corrupt than many places, but there is a list which shows we are nowhere near the least corrupt place. So I thought it would be a good idea to set up a list....  heres a start.

 

1. If you honestly tendered lower than the firm that won the govt tender, to whom can you complain?

 

2. How can you get elected without financial help? How can this possibly be without strings attached?

 

3.Why are not drug sellers routinely shopped by "customers" who are just out to get them, plus a reward?

 

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Answer to question 1 is probably nobody that's going to make any difference to the outcome. We tender for Government engineering contracts and they always have the `lowest or any tender not necessarily accepted' clause, and tenders are assessed on a number of qualitative criteria plus overall `value for money', not just lowest cost, so there is not much recourse if you are the lowest tenderer but don't get the job.

  • Like 1
  • Agree 2
  • Informative 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

The worst part about jobs tendering is the number of crooked public servants who are easily swayed with offers. The examples below are typical. Fortunately, here in W.A., we have the C.C.C. and it has real teeth to find corruption.

However, recently there's been a case where "consultants" in the public service were determined to be corrupt, and as a result, the C.C.C. had no power to charge them. The corruption processes utilised are very subtle.

 

https://www.ccc.wa.gov.au/media/news-archives/ccc-proactively-investigates-procurement-practices-western-power

 

https://www.themandarin.com.au/200592-wa-corruption-body-calls-for-new-powers-to-investigate-contractors-who-fall-outside-public-officer-scope/

 

 

Edited by onetrack
  • Informative 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

The reason there is corruption in Australia is because governments have become corrupt. It has happened very quietly over many years. Joe in Qld honestly thought he was not corrupt, but Alan Bond was convicted of bribing him. Joe was never convicted of accepting a bribe, because the trial fell apart when they got a corrupt juror on it.

The last government, led by Morrison was into all sorts of slimy business. Only today the news is about a committee of which

Morrison was Chairman and sole member having many meetings. Who did he meet and where did he find the time while he was the hidden boss of five ministries.

Corruption will always rear its ugly head if we let it and that is why so many people say discussions on religion and politics are banned at gatherings.

  • Informative 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

One of my gigs last time working in Aus was with a Vic statutory authority. I was the stream lead for procurement of a large integrated software system, which was going top replace a disparate gaggle of legacy software that was creaking at the seams and "in need of urgent replacement". I can't recall if it was an open tender or a tender by invitation only. We spent months putting together a detailed specification that the tenderers had to submit against, and would be evaluated against. We then issued the tender and spent time in supplier Q&A sessions.

 

Although I can't remember if it was an open or by invitation only tender. We were asked by the Chief Tech Officer (I think he was at the time) if we had received a submission from a specific software supplier. I knew that supplier well as I worked for competing software vendors, but I didn't know worked in this specific sector. My memory is hazy, but we were instructed to basically stop the process until we received the tender. I ignored the requiest and continued as I figurted may as well have everyone else evaluated.. as did my colleagues.

 

When this software company sent in their tender, it was the most expensice, and surprise, surprise, they would be building the software modules to support us from the ground up. In othe words, they didn't have anything off the shelf. They scored last and by a long way. When we submitted our collective evaluations, the CTO demanded to know why they were ranked last. It wasn't too hard to justify - highest risk of non-completion, highest cost, no industry experience, and the list went on. Our contracts were not renewed (which I wouldn't have, anyway), and not long after, that necessary project was terminated as the cost/benefit analysis no longer added up. Although there is nothing I can (or could have done) to prove corruption, it certainly smelled like it. And, I think, because it was a statutory authority, I think they were outside the remit of the auditor general (again, memory is hazy and could be confusing it with the UK).

 

It's not just the elected pollies that are corrupt.. Where there is opacity, a lack of accountability, and a culture of covering up, there is always going to be corruption.

 

 

  • Like 1
  • Agree 1
  • Informative 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I was involved with writing specs for tenders and evaluating them last century. Some firms always won the tendering for one big local industry, usually by $100.

One tenderer was so pissed off by this that he left the cost of formwork out of his quote and it was a substantial proportion of the job. As usual he was underquoted by $100 and Benny got the job as usual. A short while later Graham, the tenderer who left out the formwork costs got a phone call from Benny. "How did you get such a low tender price? " was the question. I don't know how it was done because the tenders were sealed right up to opening time, but someone read them early and passed the info on.

Tendering for military materials always looks decidedly dodgy and I reckon there must be kick backs for some of them to succeed, or maybe just incompetence.

Thinking back to submarines I reckon incompetence must be No 1 choice. How could we specify diesel subs, when 18 months later they were a No No.

  • Like 1
  • Informative 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

J-Oh (dear!)

8 hours ago, Bruce Tuncks said:

What do you recommend we do?

For government tenders, there should be a whistleblowing service as many that I worked with felt the same as me. This could then independently assess the pruchasing decisions made published on the criteria of the tender itself as well as government procurement standards. And where the standard fell unreasonably short or the awarded tender was unreasonably short of the reequirements (coimmercial, risk, and/or technical), both the minister responsible and the senior public servants running the procurement should be heeld to account - i.e. the whistelblowing service/review would have teeth. This obviously would choke up some larger purchases, but at the cost of careers on the line, their may be less reason to whistleblow.

  • Like 2
  • Winner 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Maybe not government corruption, but collusion when they were (under the LNP) spouting all sorts of BS about the wages pressures, etc.

 

(BTW, this guy is technically committing the act of incitement to theft..)

 

I haven't had time to double check and it is AFL Grand Final weekend.. so won't

 

 

 

Edited by Jerry_Atrick
Link to comment
Share on other sites

The bloke is right on the mark - and the high profit levels are not confined to supermarkets, either. I have never seen so many businesses that are absolutely rolling in money - and these are the same businesses who always complain that they can't afford to pay higher wages to employees.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Those businesses include aged care providers who are raking in a fortune, while paying a pittance in wages. Now the government is thinking about directly funding the wage increase for them. What does that do? As I see it the government is paying what the employer should be paying and the employer is stuffing his pockets. We have seen this so many times with government sponsored schemes, such as the school halls and roof insulation fiascos.

There is no real planning for anything nowadays, if you have a problem, throw money at it and the problem is solved. Don't look to see if the money was wisely spent because that costs more money.

  • Like 3
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 4 weeks later...

What about drugs?   I reckon their existence on the market here shows a special kind of corruption...  While the cops ( especially the feds ) are clean in that they are not taking money to look the other way, I reckon that the reason why rewards are not routinely used is that the cops like the career prospects that their monopoly includes.

For example, in my local country town, I am told that drugs are freely available, not that I have ever been offered any. But if you got a grand for telling on your supplier, and this was known and actual, then I would hate to be a drug reseller. Gosh, we would all be out there trying to buy. Then you offer the reseller a deal to betray his supplier etc.

Sure, the thing would need to be intelligently set up so it was not easy to rort, maybe this is a problem? No smarts available?

In the meantime, the cops will tell you that it would be too dangerous for "members of the public " to attempt stuff, but this is so silly that I suspect that it is not even believed by the person saying it. After all, could it be worse than taking the drugs? AND there would be a special deal for hitmen....  they would be financially better off and safe from jail, so only the dumb but loyal ones would remain.

Think about it....   the govt has unlimited money and the power to issue new identities.... plus a force of cops who are clean ...  the drug lords shouldn't stand a chance.

Edited by Bruce Tuncks
  • Like 1
  • Sad 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

If you wantr examples of corruption in Australia - some independent journos and sites will find a plethora of them. In no particular order:

  • FriendlyJordies: youtuber and "comedian" As a millenial comedian, I find his "comedy" irritating at best. And, yes, he doesn't deny, he is a Labor supporter through and through. How he hasn't had a bullet through his head, I am not sure, as he has peeved a lot of people. The latest - Clubs NSW - not the court - have launced a prosecution against him for... contempt of court!
  • Kangaroo Court of Australia. Youtuber and kangarooCourt of Australia. A bit controversial - lives in QLD and there is an arrest warrant in NSW for him for.. whistleblowing. Most western countries welcome whistleblowing. US doesn't against the government. Note, he is hyper-critical of the secret hearings for the federal ICAC (can't remember what Doofus has called it).
  • Kinghts in Shining Llama - Youtuber and one of my favourites - watch his series on the Robodebt, How the Libs have torched our legal system, and how they have used a special motion (the member should not be heard). He seems neutral on any political porty, but as the libs have been in power longer, they get the lions share.
  • Swollen Pickles  - Relatively new to the scene, but watch his (or her, I am not sure). Watch his 8 part series on the Barlilaro appointment.
  • Michael West Media
  • Independent Australia (though I think they over-hype some things)
  • Beetoota Advocate (beyond the sattire)

 

I am sure there are many more. Watching a few of these - where I think all of them procide the facts behind their assertions - does make one's blood boil somewhat.

  • Like 4
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...