Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted

I think the wiring thing is a bit of a furphy.

Most of the wiring would be at the height of the panels, ie well above the sheeps heads, and what comes down to ground level would be in conduit anyway.

Looking for problems where none exist.

  • Agree 2
Posted
2 hours ago, willedoo said:

someone who grew up on a mixed sheep, cattle and grain property.

I can see a reason here for willedoo to discount grazing under panels. He says that his home was grazing and grain. To me that means generally flat country. The country I reckon grazing and panels could work together is the uneven country just west of the Great Divide.

 

As an example of such a place, please search for Wellington Solar Farm Wuuluman NSW. That farm is about 4 kms from North to South. The land is very uneven and if you look at the surrounding land you will see that it is not grain growing land.

  • Like 1
Posted
42 minutes ago, facthunter said:

It would keep the grass eaten down

That is one of the benefits for the management of the panel farm.

 

43 minutes ago, facthunter said:

Reduce evaporation

It has been found that the microclimate under the panels is changed so that grass grows better. The sheep suffer less weather related stress which results in more wool growth, or meat growth.

 

Unintendedd consequences.

  • Like 1
Posted

This is hardly scientific, but apparently, mixing sheep farming and solar generation are becoming more common place. There is a case study towards the end of this page: https://cleanenergycouncil.org.au/for-consumers/fact-sheets/environment-and-planning-get-the-facts/renewable-energy-agriculture

 

The cabling can be run through the poles and underground with conduit meaning there is very little for the sheep to mess with. I am guessing rounding them up is more difficult but a couple of kelpies or border collies would make light work of it.. It isn't that great a cost. All solar farms around us to this anyway (but in the UK, there is not much outside transmission lines that are overhead). 

 

I agree no solar company will go into the sheep business. .they lease the land from the sheep farmer and leave the sheep farmer to continue farming sheep. The farmer opens and closes the gates. Win-win. 

  • Like 2
Posted (edited)
On 15/11/2026 at 9:54 PM, kgwilson said:

I doubt that the bill has anything to do with the cost of building a new Nuclear reactor power plant. The US has 54 Nuclear sites with 94 reactors over 28 states. The Arizona site at Palo Verde is the 2nd largest in the USA & was commissioned in 1988 so after 38 years the build cost has been well covered. The US has never dealt with the waste and after the rods have been cooled in huge underground concrete lined 40 foot deep pools for 3-5 years they are placed above ground at the same site in large concrete & steel vaults. It stays there even when the plant is decommissioned & is the responsibility of the utility company. What happens if the Utility company goes belly up is anyones guess. Given the half life of the waste is at least 10,000 years & the vaults won't even last 100 years the Yanks have a big problem looming for future generations.

 

we have a huge stable land mass right here. australia could make an industry out of storing nuclear waste. there was talk of it at coolgardie once.

i think if we are the worlds biggest supplier of uranium we have an obligation as well.

every load of scrap steel that goes to the steel mill in melbourne has to pass giega counters on the weighbridge. sometimes they get high readings from steel that people have been around for generations.

Edited by Brendan
  • Like 1
Posted

Nuclear waster storage v. nuclear power generation are two totally different things. Whilst I don't disagree we should explore developing it as an industry, I don't think there is any obligation that just because we supply uranium we have an obligation to store the waste produced as a result of its processing. Other countries have decided to take our uranium and process it to a dangerous and radioactive state for their benefit.. should the onus of dealing with the byproduct by their direct processing of the uranium for their benefit fall on them. We get compensated for the supply of it only. We don't get compensated for its use, and nor do we get any of the spoils of the provisioning for future decommissioning.. so why do we have an obligation to clean up other peoples mess because we supplied a material they use. To take that argument to its logical conclusion, we should become responsible for the environmental damage and cleanup of any overseas country who buys our natural resources and processes them for whatever it is they do with the. In two words, it's bonkas. 

 

However, that does not mean we should not explore the possibility of developing an environmentally safe storage capability we can market to the world for a profit.. just as we should look and any other economic opportunity in any industry. But to suggest we have an obligation is nuts, IMHO. 

 

But when taking into account the safe storage in Australia, there is this thing called transporting it and the risks associated with that, too. We are quite a way from the countries most likely to utilise our services, and as with oil, there is a risk that will sometime materialise that could cause radiation to seep out. Building the transport capability to withstand those risks won't be cheap.. but we shoudl look at that, too. 

 

Posted
15 minutes ago, Brendan said:

every load of scrap steel that goes to the steel mill in melbourne has to pass giega counters on the weighbridge. sometimes they get high readings from steel that people have been around for generations.

A couple of engines to give a wide berth to are the Mirage Snecma and the RR Viper they had in the Macchi. The Snecma is the worst. I've taken readings on both and the dosimeter started squealing ten feet away from the Snecma compressor. 

  • Informative 1
Posted

i disagree about not being responsible. 

we have bowen running around skiting about australia being a leader in renewables and 

cutting emissions but at the same time we are sending millions of tons of coal to the highest polluters.

that is just moving the problem away but its still a problem.

At least uranium gets used for clean power i guess. there are a lot of people that think we should take 

some responsibility for nuclear waste .

 

  • Informative 1
Posted
2 minutes ago, willedoo said:

A couple of engines to give a wide berth to are the Mirage Snecma and the RR Viper they had in the Macchi. The Snecma is the worst. I've taken readings on both and the dosimeter started squealing ten feet away from the Snecma compressor. 

is that from the metals used in them. dumb question sorry.

Posted

If you want to understand what proper storage of Nuclear waste is like, look up the Onkalo spent fuel repository in Finland. It is located approximately 400 to 450 meters (1,300 to 1,500 feet) underground inside 1.9-billion-year-old crystalline bedrock and took 20 years to build.

  • Agree 1
  • Informative 1
Posted
32 minutes ago, Brendan said:

At least uranium gets used for clean power i guess. there are a lot of people that think we should take 

some responsibility for nuclear waste .

Emission free.. But far from clean.   First, the amount of concrete used in them is massive - Hinkley point C has over 3m tonnes of concrete - that is one unit in a two unit plant. 

 

Secondly, it produces radioactive waste. That isn't very clean. We can manage it, but it ain't clean.


Re who has responsibility for clean up.. that's a value judgement and there is no one right answer. But, if we are responsible for it, wouldn't that imply we have to to do it. Which would mean whether we want to or not, and whether it is profitable or not.. And if it is not pre-contracted that the users will pay for it and not included in the purchase price, being responsible would mean we would have to do it whether they pay us or not?

 

That is responsibility. 

Posted

I have always wandered what the amount of concrete/TWh in a NPP verses a WTG. Before I left the wind industry there was a news letter come out that they had just poured the first 1100 cubic metre gravity base on a windfarm in Queensland. At 2.7t per cubic metre that is pushing 3000t for a turbine that puts out less then 6MW less the capacity factor closer to 2MW( less then 30% according to google but that may have some utilisation factor in it as well.) I think Hinkley is a 3.2 GW station with probably a possible capacity factor in the 90% range. I also believe that the EPR is fairly heavy on the concrete use because it has a double containment  but they have reduced it in the EPR2. Given that the windfarm will need to be replaced at least once during the life of the NP as well. It may be closer to being the same then we think, especially when we start considering the extra needed for the WTGs like batterys (pumped hydro being the big user) 

 

450m sounds like a lot. Deepest part of Olympic Dam mine is 900m

Posted
11 hours ago, Jerry_Atrick said:

so why do we have an obligation to clean up other peoples mess because we supplied a material they use.

On the flip side, just look at the tonnages of used packaging materials we end up with from what we import. Should we telling China to take back the packaging that comes with the stuff they export to us? That's gunna happen - Not!

 

We have a massive problem with packaguing waste. There's bugger all you can do with it. It is of such low value that it costs more to recycle it that what you can get from it once you recycle it. It's not just the costs of recycling packaging in a factory situation. The other costs come from trying to move the stuff to the factory and the prcessed stuff out to a market, if there is one.

 

Again this week I sent off over 200 kgs of unwanted fabric, in the form of clothing that was unsuitable for resale, for recycling overseas, as well as sending a bit to landfill. Usually I drop off a few kilos of cardboard for recycling as well. Next time you are in ColesWorths, look at the amount of cardboard that their goods come in and think how they have to get rid of it.

 

So, if we sell  coffinite and brannerite, which are common uranium ore minerals in certain deposits (including in Australia), then it should be the responsibility of the final user to get rid of the waste. Could they pay Australia to store it? Why not. Business is business, but can you imagine the outcry by environmentalists?

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...