Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted

If you could guarantee a benevolent, integral and peaceful dictatorship, life in theory would be very good. But, alas, it isn;t a sustainable feature of humanity. 

 

2 hours ago, Marty_d said:

Where the hell will the Greens direct their preferences, if not Labor?

Independents? Even if the independent was inconsistent with your ideology, the power they wield is limited. 

Posted

When things get Politicised, Truth goes out the door. The Libs promises need COSTING. It has not been done and the greens pile on Labor to get the Low hanging fruit for their Own purposes.ie Getting a higher percentage.They Know they Can never govern in their own right, so can promise Knowing they won't have to deliver. Nev

Posted
5 hours ago, Marty_d said:

Where the hell will the Greens direct their preferences, if not Labor?

In 15 seats they are directing on how to vote cards Greens 1, One Nation last and no preferences in between.

  • Informative 1
Posted

 According to Tony Barry, historical preference flows show Green voters don't closely follow their how to vote cards. In past state and federal elections exhausted green votes have gone roughly 85% to Labor, 15% to the Coalition.

  • Informative 1
Posted

I read an article in The Age today of the unlikely PHON voters.. It was taken from Pakenham to Gippsland and based on who the journos interacted with. The Sri Lankan community look like they are very much in favour of PHON citing the need to get immigration under control and focus on importing skilled migrants. 

 

Of course, the mines and power stations winding down have had an impact. As usual, governments of all colours allow it to happen without necessary transition plans. Replacing whole industries with a few more public servants hasn't cut it. 

 

There were those who have also been struggling, and an ex union leader. 

 

Of course, it's not statistically valid enough to say what will happen, but as I sit at the airport and reflect, there does appear to be a groundswell of fundamental discontent with the state of play.

 

I bumped into an ex work colleague fro London, who is Australian and repatriated about 10 years go. He is in work but his concern is it may not last for long. His assertion is that as the latest wave ot IT immigrants are climbing the corporate ladder, they aseem to be favouring their own and not being too equal-opportunity focused. 

 

I would normally discount it as someone having a bit of a whinge because they are being overlooked for others better than them, but this bloke has worked for me and I know his capabilities. Assuming he was not lying, he described situations where consistently others far more competent were overlooked for those of similar backgrounds - that resulted in near disaster (in corporate terms of course, which mean screing something up but not ending the earth). 

 

Whether or not it is true, perceptions matter and sadly most of the electorate take perception over fact. And that weighs on peoples minds.

 

And the corruption - it seems mind boggling (on all three major sides).

 

Posted (edited)
4 hours ago, Jerry_Atrick said:

I read an article in The Age today of the unlikely PHON voters.. It was taken from Pakenham to Gippsland and based on who the journos interacted with. The Sri Lankan community look like they are very much in favour of PHON citing the need to get immigration under control and focus on importing skilled migrants. 

 

Of course, the mines and power stations winding down have had an impact. As usual, governments of all colours allow it to happen without necessary transition plans. Replacing whole industries with a few more public servants hasn't cut it. 

 

There were those who have also been struggling, and an ex union leader. 

 

Of course, it's not statistically valid enough to say what will happen, but as I sit at the airport and reflect, there does appear to be a groundswell of fundamental discontent with the state of play.

 

I bumped into an ex work colleague fro London, who is Australian and repatriated about 10 years go. He is in work but his concern is it may not last for long. His assertion is that as the latest wave ot IT immigrants are climbing the corporate ladder, they aseem to be favouring their own and not being too equal-opportunity focused. 

 

I would normally discount it as someone having a bit of a whinge because they are being overlooked for others better than them, but this bloke has worked for me and I know his capabilities. Assuming he was not lying, he described situations where consistently others far more competent were overlooked for those of similar backgrounds - that resulted in near disaster (in corporate terms of course, which mean screing something up but not ending the earth). 

 

Whether or not it is true, perceptions matter and sadly most of the electorate take perception over fact. And that weighs on peoples minds.

 

And the corruption - it seems mind boggling (on all three major sides).

 

the corruption is all jacinta allan and dan andrews in vic. union puppets.

the week before allan was thrown out she was trying to have the rates cap introduced by Andrews removed to gain support to keep her job. she was happy for all rate payers in victoria to get slugged more as long as it benefitted her.

i know i will cop abuse for saying that from the left. like that idiot telling me to leave the country.

every person i speak too is voting one nation and most of them used to vote labor as i did myself.

albo and chalmers plan to bring house prices down is working. my trucks deliver construction materials and our work has dried up. usually from september to christmas i can't keep up and we bring extra carriers in. this year i have trucks parked up. getting about 3 days a week and parked up by lunch time. there are going to be a lot of people hurting this christmas.

its ok if your on the big build or a public servant.

 

Edited by Brendan
Posted
2 hours ago, Brendan said:

like that idiot telling me to leave the country.

FFS Brendan. That was meant as a joke. I've been trying for days to find a way to pour oil on the troubled waters between us, but I couldn't think of words that would be misconstrued as being offensive.

 

Posted (edited)
16 minutes ago, old man emu said:

FFS Brendan. That was meant as a joke. I've been trying for days to find a way to pour oil on the troubled waters between us, but I couldn't think of words that would be misconstrued as being offensive.

 

fair enough. i will drop it .

i am still wary of comments directed at me after the one calling me a wife basher because i don't like labor.  

i have done my fair share of offending . i am trying to behave.

 

Edited by Brendan
Posted
12 hours ago, Brendan said:

fair enough. i will drop it

Happy to hear that. 

 

However, I don't think it was me who made that offensive comment you quote. Honestly, the term is not one that comes readily to me. 

 

But enough. The hatchet is well and truely buried.

Posted

I can't remember wher you live, Nev, but for a bloke from NSW, Victorians are Mexicans cause they live south of the border. A Queenslander is a banana bender. A South Australian is a crow eater. A Western Australian is a sand groper. A New South Welshman is a cornstalk. A Tasmanian is inbred. :taz:

  • Haha 1
Posted

All of them are silly names for  a state ( except SA & WA and they are unimaginative in the extreme. ARE Tasmanians MANIC.?  Who would want to be a Queen in Queens Land? IF NSW is South wales where is the rest of Wales?  Nev

Posted
On 16/11/2026 at 11:17 AM, red750 said:

I'm gonna stop watching TV for the next two weeks. I'm sick to death of those election ads every ad break.

the leaders debate on news 24 last night was interesting.  jess wilson really stood out. 

ben carroll was just a self absorbed joke. felt a bit sorry for him. the greens leader just kept repeating don't vote for the other 3 because they are in big business pockets and we need free everything because we are greens and should be given everything.

warren pickering was good. to the point and not talking rubbish.

100 people in the audience voted. jess wilson 39%.   ben carrol 7%.  greens woman 25% 

pickering  around 24% i think. 

just a small poll but labour is so far down i can't see how they can win.

Posted

He's a pretty capable person  and there's not much (if any) dissention in the ranks. Unlike the LIBS who are at each other's throats and have been for years. (and NO . I'm not making it up. Nev

Posted

As much as i hate to admit it as it helps the city people a lot more than country people, free public transport would be a way to cut down transport emmissions.

Posted
10 hours ago, facthunter said:

He's a pretty capable person  and there's not much (if any) dissention in the ranks. Unlike the LIBS who are at each other's throats and have been for years. (and NO . I'm not making it up. Nev

thats the only comment you ever seem to have.  labour have proven they should not govern victoria.

they have achieved some great things like the crossing removals and footsgray and sunshine hospitals

but the bad outweighs the good. 

Posted
On 19/11/2026 at 11:56 AM, Brendan said:

thats the only comment you ever seem to have.  labour have proven they should not govern victoria.

they have achieved some great things like the crossing removals and footsgray and sunshine hospitals

but the bad outweighs the good. 

To name a few of the achievements of Labor in Vic:

  • Removal of most level crossings in Melbourne (although I think the money could have been better spent)
  • Metro tunnel
  • West Gate tunnel 
  • Voluntary assisted dying (not everyone will agree that is an achievement)
  • legalised medicinal cannabis
  • Women's health safe access zones
  • Medically supervised self-injection rooms
  • First people's treat (not everyone will agree)
  • Criminalising wage theft
  • Compensation for victims of institutionalised child abuse
  • Free TAFE (again, after the LNP smashed it)
  • There seems to have been an amazing level of road improvements and development despite the cancellation of part of the East Link.

 

Some of the issues they have had:

  • CMFEU corruption scandal
  • Restrictions on the Royal Commission not to include Jacinta Allan's conduct
  • Rising debt - All of the big build had to be paid for (well, except for the alleged $15bn of CMFEU enrichment). 
  • Slightly higher unemployment compared to other states Slightly higher cost of living as well
  • Increase in crime - especially violent knife crime, illegal tobacco, etc.
  • Relaxation of bail laws (resulting in the above)
  • Shortfalls in police numbers also attributed to the above.
  • A few other union corruption deals including the training contract to the state government of the heath workers union
  • Other corruption thanks to a narrow definition of corruption under IBAC and its opacity (a bit like the NACC). 
  • And of course, their branch stacking controversy. 
  • Public swimming pools in roads (aka potholes)
  • Degradation of education facilities. 

 

I am sure there are more achievements and more issues. But the reality is they have had their time, hubris has set in, the corruption seems as blatant as the Libs - if not worse and things that matter to the people - crime, potholes, education, health, etc, seem to have taken a hit against the big build especially, of which the detailes are starting to emerge. 

 

On state debt - yes it is high. However, after chronic underinvestment from successive governments of both colours, something needed to be done. But, some of the investment decisions were not geared for long term growth, so once the build was over, the $ stopped flowing. 

 

On both of my trips this year, the sour taste in the mouths of people is the corruption and hubris. The economic performance was a minor headache from what I could see.  

 

This election is not about picking the best; its about punishing the incumbents. The libs don't really have an answer, and PHON offers a lot of false hope aka MAGA Maniac himself.  

 

  • Informative 1

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...